The data include car sales of Ferrari, Lambogini, and Maserati for the years 2010,2011,2012 for Italy. This is obviously a time series plot but the graphic designer thought for some reason that the graphic should be a bar chart, half circle, and half of the picture should be upside down. Why not just have something like this?
I know my graphic has half years (which don't mean anything) and the labels for car manufactures are cut off. I still think its a more informative graphic than the one C and D produced. What do you think?